Home Vacuum Zone is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com
Makita and Dyson are well-established brands that manufacture different home appliances such as vacuums, heaters, and dryers. Makita is a much older brand established in 1915, whereas Dyson, a British technology company, was established much later in 1987.
Over the years, with technological advancements, better floor cleaning tools have made doing the job easy and comfortable. Whilst Dyson are best known for making vacuum cleaners, Makita are well known for producing a wide range of cordless power tools. One of the benefits of a Makita Stick Vacuum vs Dyson for many is that their batteries are interchangeable with those used for other Makita devices.
The Makita® LXT® cordless system takes you from power tools to vacuums to get the job done. Utilizing 18V lithium-ion slide style batteries, the LXT® system works with 300 + cordless products.
https://www.makitatools.com/cleaning
Makita vs Dyson Stick Vacuums
The main differences between Makita and Dyson Stick vacuums come down to weight, performance and price.
Makita stick vacuums weigh less than Dysons because they do not have a motorized brush head. As a result the cleaning performance of the Makita stick vacuums are limited to cleaning surface dirt. They are therefore only suitable for cleaning hard floors or low pile carpets.
On the other hand, the Dyson sticks are suitable for replacing full sized corded vacuums for deep cleaning of any floor surfaces.
Dyson stick vacuums however are much more expensive than Makita sticks.
In this article, we take a deep look at the other similarities and differences between Makita stick and Dyson vacuums and help you choose the best one to suit your need and use. The following models from Makita and Dyson are considered.
#1 – Makita XLC04R1BX4 Vacuum Kit
This cordless vacuum is a compact and powerful vacuum with excellent suction capacity. With this vacuum, you can clean fast and efficiently. With the included 2.0Ah battery the Makita vacuum can run for up to 33 minutes of continuous use in low speed. You can increase this by purchasing the larger 5.0Ah battery that delivers up to 83 minutes of continuous use.
Features
- Weight: This ergonomic and compact size vacuum weighs just 2.7 lbs. This makes it easy to clean and store.
- Dirt Capacity: This stick vacuum can store around 0.20 gallons of dirt.
- Filtration: It comes with bagless cloth filtration that makes cleaning easy and faster disposal of the dirtbag.
- Power: This vacuum comes with 3-variable speed power to choose the setting appropriate for use.
- Warranty: It comes with a 3-year warranty period.
- Noise Level: This vacuum operates quietly at less than 63dB. This is a very quiet vacuum!
- Tools Included: It comes with a 2.0Ah battery, charger, floor nozzles, crevice, and a cloth filter.
Pros
- Bagless design
- Very quiet operation.
- Swappable battery for longer cleaning with multiple batteries or a larger battery.
- Super fast charging – fully charge the 2.0Ah battery in only 25 minutes. This compares to several hours for Dyson Stick vacuums.
- Very lightweight – less than half the weight of the Dyson.
- Long warranty.
Cons
- Some users do not find the vacuum durable.
- Filtration is non-HEPA and not as good as on the Dyson
- No motorized brush head
#2 – Makita XLC05R1WX4 Vacuum
This compact and ergonomically designed vacuum is easy to use and can operate for around 33 minutes at low speed when fully charged using the included 2.0Ah battery. Longer runtimes are available with a larger battery. This is a bagged model
Features
- Weight: This compact vacuum weighs just 2.8 lbs. This lightweight vacuum is specially made to reduce operator fatigue.
- Dirt Capacity: For convenience, this accepts disposable cloth bags, making cleaning easy.
- Filtration: It uses non-HEPA filtration and a paper filter to capture dust and dirt.
- Power: It comes with 3-speed power and works efficiently. The powerful Makita-built motor delivers up to 53 CFM.
- Warranty: 3-year limited warranty.
- Noise Level: It works quietly at 65 dB.
Pros
- Very lightweight & compact
- Fast charging -fully charge the 2.0Ah battery in only 25 minutes
- Ergonomic handle.
Cons
- As this is a bagged model, cost of replacement bags needs to be considered.
- Some users find it does not clean flooring thoroughly.
- Filtration is not as good compared to the Dyson.
- No motorized brush head.
#3 – Dyson V8
This is an extremely lightweight and versatile vacuum and can operate for 40 minutes. Its ergonomic handle makes it easy to clean.
Features
- Weight. It weighs 5.63 lbs and is pretty compact.
- Dirt Capacity. This vacuum stores relatively less dust in the bag, up to 0.14 gallons.
- Filtration. It fully-sealed filtration and traps 99% of dirt with HEPA filtration.
- Power. It does not come with different power modes but still has a strong suction capacity to capture dust and small particles. Max Suction Power is 115AW.
- Tools Included. This product comes with a soft roller cleaner, crevice, motorized tool, and dusting brush.
Pros
- Powerful suction and very good cleaning performance
- HEPA Filtration
- Versatile – converts easily to handheld vacuum mode.
Cons
- The battery life is relatively short (up to 40 mins runtime in low power mode), requiring more frequent charges.
- Much heavier than the Makita Stick
- Battery not swappable
#4 – Dyson V10
This vacuum has a strong suction capacity and cleans faster than many vacuums out there. With an advanced filtration system, it can capture 99% of the dirt particles.
Features
- Weight. It weighs 5.9 lbs. This lightweight and bagless vacuum make it easy to clean.
- Dirt Capacity. It can store up to 0.20 gallons of dirt in its dust bag.
- Filtration. It can capture 99% dirt particles and expel clean air with fully sealed filtration.
- Power. Its digital motor has a powerful suction capacity of up to 151AW.
- Noise Level. This vacuum is acoustically engineered and eliminates unpleasant tones. Noise levels vary between 72-80dB depending on the power setting modes. Refer to our full review of the Dyson V10 for further details.
Pros
- Long battery Life – up to 60 minutes of run time
- Powerful suction and exceptional cleaning performance
- Best filtration
Cons
- Expensive.
- The noise the V10 makes in Max Mode is relatively loud, which may be unpleasant to some users.
- Trigger must be constantly pressed when cleaning.
- Battery not swappable.
#5 – Dyson V11
The Dyson V11 is excellent for deep cleaning and easily removes dirt and small particles from carpets and hard floors. Check out our comparison of the Dyson V11 with the V10 and V8 for further details.
Features
- Weight. It weighs 6.68 lbs and is perfect for deep cleaning.
- Dirt Capacity. This vacuum comes with 0.2 gallons of bin bag to store dirt.
- Filtration. Its fully-sealed filtration system traps 99% of the dirt particles.
- Power. It comes with three power modes eco, auto, and boost. You can change the mode as per your use. Max suction power is 185 Air Watts.
- Noise Level. This vacuum is a bit loud at a sound of 80dB when on boost mode.
Pros
- It takes less time to clean
- Great suction power.
- Dyson fixes the high-pitched noise issue that was an annoyance in the V10.
Cons
- Short battery life on boost mode.
- Quite loud but only on boost mode, which you may use only on occasion.
#6 – Dyson V15
The V15 is Dyson’s most powerful vacuum cleaner, and it is much more efficient in cleaning dirt and dust and doing so thoroughly. This is currently Dyson’s latest model with additional features you don’t get with earlier versions such as the laser fluffy cleaner head and hair screw tool. The Dyson V15 is the best stick vacuum cleaner in the market for features and performance. However, as a result it is the most expensive.
Features
- Weight. It weighs 6.8 lbs and is easy to clean.
- Dirt Capacity. The dirtbag can store 0.2 gallons of dust.
- Filtration. It comes with HEPA filtration and can trap 99% of dirt particles.
- Power. This vacuum has three power modes so that you can choose the correct mode as per need and use. Max suction is
- Noise Level. It operates at 69dB and does not get very loud.
Pros
- Relatively more powerful than Dyson’s previous models.
Cons
- Dyson’s newest flagship is expensive.
- Quite heavy for a stick vacuum and much heavier than the Makita Sticks.
Comparison: Makita Stick Vacuum vs Dyson
Weight
When we look at the weight of these vacuums, the Makita stick vacuums are much lighter than the Dyson models. Both the models of Makita stick vacuums discussed above are made to reduce operator fatigue, and their ergonomic design handle provides better comfort while cleaning.
The Dyson models weigh between 5 lbs to 7 lbs, whereas the Makita stick vacuums weigh less than 3 lbs.
Dirt Capacity
The Makita vacuum cleaner comes with a large disposable bag to store all the dirt up to 0.20 gallons.
The Dyson vacuum models can also store 0.2 gallons of dirt, except the Dyson V8, which stores just 0.14 gallons of dirt. However, it is easy to empty the dirtbag after cleaning.
Power
The Makita vacuum cleaners come with three power modes controlled using a push button. It offers excellent efficiency and has powerful suction, up to 53 CFM. CFM stands for Cubic Feet per Minute and is a measure of a vacuum’s air flow. For more on that go here.
The Dyson models discussed above come with three power modes except for Dyson V8. The Dyson V15 has excellent suction power and comes with anti-tangle technology and laser cleaner that can help remove dust that is hard to see from the floors. Dyson V15 is much more efficient in cleaning the carpets and floors thoroughly.
Suction power on Dyson vacuums are specified in Air Watts and therefore aren’t readily comparable to the CFM rating on Makita Stick vacuums. However, our review of estimated CFM ratings in published reviews of the Dyson stick vacuums included in this article are all well above the CFM air flow of the Makita sticks. As a result, it is clear that the Dyson sticks have much more powerful suction compared to the Makitas. In addition the Dysons have motorized brush heads to ensure thorough cleaning of all floor surface types.
Filtration
The Makita vacuums use bagless cloth filtration, making it easy to clean and dispose of the dirtbag. In comparison, the Dyson model comes with a fully sealed filtration system and traps 99% of the dust particles as small as 0.3 microns. The Dyson V15 uses HEPA filtration and is the most versatile cordless vacuum cleaner.
Final Thoughts
Both Makita and Dyson are reputable brands known for their performance and quality. You can choose a vacuum cleaner from this list to suit your need and use.
Overall, the Dyson V15 comes with the most advanced features and technology and can even pick long hairs and pet hairs. It is much more efficient than Dyson’s previous offerings and has 100% more suction power than other models.
However, it is one of the most expensive consumer vacuums available on the market right now, so it will be up to you to determine whether it is within your budget. If not the V15, Dyson and Makita have several other vacuums in their product line that may suit your needs as well.
Last update on 2024-10-08 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API