Tineco vs Dyson cordless vacuum – Which is Best?

In the world of cordless vacuums, Dyson has long been revered as the premium choice. But with Tineco entering the scene, offering affordable alternatives that claim to match Dyson's performance, the 'Tineco vs Dyson' debate has never been more relevant.

As we explore the strengths and weaknesses of each brand, we aim to help you make an informed decision for your home. We also compare the performance of the latest and best-selling Tineco and Dyson models:

Let's get into it.

Tineco vs Dyson Specifications Compared

Tineco Pure One S15

The Tineco Pure One S15 Pro is a high-end cordless stick vacuum that has garnered attention for its performance and features. We have spent hours reviewing this vacuum including several third party tests to provide this detailed assessment.

Performance Metrics

• Suction Power: Powerful suction, adjusts power automatically
• Brush Roll Performance: Large motorized anti-tangle brush, V-shaped bristles designed to prevent hair wrapping.

Key Features

• Design: Sleek, premium build with an upgraded LCD display
• Maneuverability: Lightweight and easy to maneuver, although the Dyson has better handling due to its rotating ball design.
• Accessories: Mini power brush, slimline crevice tool, 2-in-1 dust brush, hair cleaning tool, extra pre-filter, and a charging stand.
• Smart Features: Smartphone connectivity with Tineco app for iOS and Android.

Pros

• Lightweight, premium build;
• Fixes most complaints about the Pure One S12;
• Powerful suction;
• Adjusts power automatically - efficient use of battery;
• Cleans well on most surfaces;
• Clever LCD screen.

Cons

• Middling battery life - approximately half the time of the Dyson V15;
• Poor test results for large debris pickup on hard floors;
• 465ml bin is on the small side;
• Filter gets soiled rather quickly;
• Bin can’t be fully removed;
• Edge performance could be better;

Dyson V15 Detect

The Dyson V15 Detect is hailed as the most powerful cordless vacuum available, boasting an impressive 230 AW of suction power!

It comes equipped with a click-in battery system, providing a run time of up to 60 minutes. However, we note that third party tests have confirmed runtimes up to 85 minutes in low power mode!

Like the Tineco S15, the Dyson V15 also features adaptive suction power for to optimize battery use. In addition, it includes two primary cleaning heads: the High Torque Motorbar for carpets and the Laser Slim Fluffy for hard surfaces.

A unique feature of the V15 is its internal sensor that displays detailed cleaning data, showing the types and sizes of particles being vacuumed. 

Key Features

• Reactive suction power that adjusts to different conditions.
• Digital display screen that provides data on particle size, cleaning modes, and remaining run time.
• The Fluffy cleaning head comes with a green light laser to illuminate dust and smaller debris particles.
• The V15 has an advanced digital display on the back of the motor that shows run time, maintenance alerts, and cleaning reports based on an internal particulate sensor.
• The V15 introduces the Fluffy soft roller cleaning head and an upgraded version of the High Torque head.

Pros

• Up to 60-minute run time with a click-in battery. Tested runtimes show even longer runtimes. 
• Washable Fluffy cleaning head and High Torque cleaner head.
• Digital display with data on particle size, cleaning modes, and remaining run time.
• Best cleaning performance and filtration in the cordless vacuum market.

Cons

• It is one of the most expensive models available.
• Battery is swappable but a spare is expensive to buy.

Performance

The V15 demonstrated excellent cleaning performance across various surfaces.

• On hardwood floors, the vacuum removed 100% of all debris types, with the front laser light aiding in visibility for finer debris. 
• On low pile carpet, the V15 removed 99.3% of total debris, while on high pile carpets, it removed 98.8% of total debris.

Design

The V15 Detect retains the familiar design of the Dyson V series but introduces several innovative features.

These include a floor-level laser to highlight dust particles, a Piezo sensor to count and measure dust particle size, and an ultra-advanced digital display that provides real-time feedback on cleaning performance.

Usability

The V15 is user-friendly and incorporates several features from previous models while introducing new ones. Notable features enhancing usability include a click-in battery, up to 60-minute run time, a washable Fluffy cleaning head, a point-and-shoot debris canister, and three cleaning modes (Eco, Auto, and Boost).

Comparison: Dyson V15 Detect Vs Tineco Pure One S15

Suction Power Tests

The table below provides a comparison of the suction power between the Dyson V15 and the Tineco Pure One S15 from our review of third party test data.

As can be seen the max suction power on the Dyson is better than the Tineco. However, surprisingly the sealed suction tests resulted in the same for both models. 

Runtime Tests

The table below provides a comparison of the runtimes between the Dyson V15 and the Tineco Pure One S15 from our review of third party test data.

As can be seen the runtimes in Eco mode for the Dyson are much longer than the longest runtime available from the Tineco (in Auto mode).

There is also a large variation in tested runtimes for the Dyson in Eco mode. This is due to variations in floor surface and whether the motorized brush bar is used.

Both Tineco and Dyson models have removable batteries so that you can swap with a spare for added runtimes.

These are purchased separately for the Dyson but comes included with the Tineco Pure One S15 Pet Ex. However, this model of Tineco will cost you as much as the Dyson.

Similar Features

• Display: Both vacuums feature digital displays, but the Dyson V15's display provides data on particle size, cleaning modes, and remaining run time, whereas the Tineco's display focuses on cleaning performance and battery life.
• Sensors: The Dyson V15 comes with an internal sensor that reveals detailed cleaning data, while the Tineco Pure One S15 features iLoop Dust Sensor technology that adjusts suction power in real-time.

Performance

• Hardwood Floors: Both vacuums perform exceptionally well on hardwood floors, with the Dyson V15's Fluffy cleaning head offering a slight edge with its laser light feature.
• Carpet Cleaning: The Dyson V15 and Tineco Pure One S15 both deliver impressive results on carpets, with minor differences in debris removal percentages.

Conclusion

Both the Dyson V15 Detect and the Tineco Pure One S15 are top-tier cordless vacuums, each with its own set of unique features and benefits.

The choice between the two ultimately depends on whether the extra cost of the Dyson is worth it to you for the extra performance and features. Is it worth it to you? 

Something further to consider:

In addition to the better overall performance, accessories and features, Dyson is a trusted vacuum brand built on many years of vacuum cleaner manufacturing. Their vacuums are made to last a long time and they have a history of being the best.

By contrast, Tineco is a new entrant and has not yet proven itself as a long term competitor to Dyson. 

Dyson Cyclone V10 Motorhead

Dyson released the V10 in 2018 but its performance still competes with the latest cordless models on the market. It features a HEPA filtration system along with very powerful suction, which can almost match the suction power of corded vacuums.

We talk about this further in our Dyson V10 Review, so check that out to see how this cordless vacuum compares to a full powered corded upright.

Furthermore, the V10 Motorhead is the product of many years of refinement by Dyson and is one of the company’s best selling cordless vacuums. 

Features

Pros

Cons

Video Review

Tineco A11 Pet Cordless

Whilst the Tineco brand is relatively unknown, they build cordless vacuums that incorporate lots of remarkable features to suit all your home cleaning needs.

It includes a filtration system that is completely sealed using a HEPA filter which works great at shaking up, capturing and then retaining even the tiniest dust particles as well as pet hair. Therefore, thanks to this useful feature, you can be sure that the dust from your carpets won't escape back into your home.

Despite this cordless vacuum not having a washable filter, you can still clean it using a tool that comes along with it. Therefore, you do not need to wait for hours before you can resume your cleaning duties.

Features

Pros

Cons

Video Review

Conclusion 

Having read through this review, you now have an idea of both the differences and similarities between the Dyson V10 Motorhead and the Tineco A11 Master. With the Dyson cordless vacuum, you get a machine that has worldwide recognition for its reliability. Both of these vacuum cleaners also are very powerful, maneuverable as well as incorporate an incredible filtration system.

The Tineco A11 Master, on the other hand, is relatively new in this industry. Nevertheless, it still is an excellent option, and a close inspection of its features shows it without a doubt gives the Dyson V10 serious competition.

The Tineco A11 Master is more expensive compared to the Dyson V10 Motorhead, and according to customer reviews, this product is exceptional quality and it guarantees you the highest performance. Dyson too has a long history of producing high-quality vacuums. Therefore, with this in mind, it is up to you to decide which between these two cordless vacuums you feel best meets your needs.