Home Vacuum Zone is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com
Miele and Dyson are two very popular and well known vacuum brands. We have reviewed their vacuums many times but this direct comparison of Miele vs Dyson will help you decide between the two if you are stuck. There are both similarities and differences between the brands and the vacuums that they manufacture. We already have our favourite but if you read the in-depth analysis that follows you can decide for yourself if Miele or Dyson is for you.
We've paired up the following vacuums for our Miele vs Dyson comparison, which you will find in the sections below:
We took a detailed look at the Miele brand in this article, which reveals that most Miele vacuums are made in Germany. Dyson, by comparison, have engineering teams involved in the design and manufacture of their vacuum cleaners across the globe. Dyson's research and development is done at their headquarters in Malmesbury, United Kingdom, however most of their manufacturing is undertaken in Malaysia after this was relocated from Britain in 2002.
Miele are a much older company than Dyson, having been established in 1899 whereas Sir James Dyson founded the Dyson company in 1991. Miele manufacture a broad range of other home appliances in addition to vacuum cleaners including washing machines, dryers, refrigerators and dishwashers. Although Dyson's brand was built around their innovative vacuum cleaners they have moved into other markets including air treatment appliances and hand dryers as well as their more recent entries into the lighting and hair dryer markets.
Both Miele and Dyson have brought about new innovations in the vacuum cleaner industry. Miele were the creator of the world's first HEPA certified vacuum cleaner in the 1990s whilst Dyson were introducing the world's first bagless vacuum cleaner.
Comparison between Miele and Dyson vacuum cleaners
Miele vs Dyson Vacuum Types
In terms of vacuum cleaners, both Miele and Dyson manufacture the main types: upright, canister, stick and robot. Dyson also produce a handheld vacuum but Miele do not.
Miele vs Dyson Technology
The technology in both Dyson and Miele vacuums provide excellent filtration and expel only clean air. This is due to their systems being engineered to be completely sealed. This is an important feature and stands their vacuums apart from other cheaper vacuums in the market. These airtight systems ensure that what goes into the vacuum goes into the clear bin or dust bag - not back into the home.
The main difference between Miele and Dyson vacuums is that Miele's vacuums use a bag for the dust collection whereas Dyson vacuums are bagless and now even filterless. The technology used by Miele vs Dyson in their vacuums is therefore quite different. Having to purchase replacement bags and filters means the cost of running a Miele is more than a Dyson.
Due to all of the dust being trapped inside the dust bag, some consider the operation and maintenance of a Miele to be better than with a Dyson. Users have reported that emptying a Miele is safer for allergy sufferers than with a Dyson as the dust bag is sealed upon removal allowing no dust to escape. Miele's are also reported to require less periodic cleaning than a Dyson, again due to the differences in technology.
Another difference in Miele versus Dyson technology is noise output. Most Mieles are quieter than Dysons. This has been recorded in various independent tests and you will notice that Miele regularly highlight that their vacuums are amongst the quietest you can buy. The Miele Silence-System technology includes a noise optimized motor and integrated sound insulation to provide for a quiet vacuuming experience.
Which technology is best, Miele or Dyson? We explore this in detail below by comparing Miele vs Dyson specific vacuum models.
Miele vs Dyson Vacuum Range
Another difference between the Miele and Dyson brands is that Miele produce a larger range of models of vacuum cleaner than Dyson. There are currently over 20 different canister vacuums in the Miele range. In comparison, Dyson only make 3 canister models. There are also 8 different Miele upright models compared to the 7 models in the Dyson upright range.
The larger range of vacuums on offer from Miele means that they cater for a larger variation of requirements and budgets in comparison to Dyson. The Miele vacuum range costs from $300 for the entry level models to over $1000 for the top of the range model. This compares to Dyson's vacuums costing from $300 to a little over $600.
Miele vs Dyson Warranty
Both Miele and Dyson produce premium vacuums that are built to last and back this up with some of the best warranties you can get. Miele vacuums undergo rigorous testing in the factory to simulate 20 years of use. This compares to Dyson vacuums, which are engineered and tested to last 10 years.
All Dyson vacuums come with a 5 year warranty, except their cordless models, which have a 2 year warranty.
Miele vacuums come with a 7 year warranty on their motor and casing and a 1 year warranty on all other components. Except for its cordless models which, like the Dyson come with a 2 year warranty.
However, Miele vacuums are also backed by the Good Housekeeping Limited Warranty Seal. The Seal means that Good Housekeeping will replace or refund defective products within two years of purchase.
Miele vacuum cleaners
Miele's slogan is "Immer Besser" which translates to "forever better". This slogan is representative of the company's philosophy and the Miele brand is widely recognised for unsurpassed product quality. Miele aims to manufacture the highest-quality vacuums in the world and it would be fair to say that they are achieving their aim.
Miele vacuum cleaners offer an ideal combination of superior cleaning performance, ease of use, outstanding hygiene standards and first-class quality.
Miele vacuums feature multi-stage filtration and a certified air sealed system ensuring only clean air is released while vacuuming. Their focus on hygiene necessitates the use of multi-layered filter bags for collecting the dust and dirt. The bags have an automatically closing collar to ensure that its contents are reliably locked inside when removed. Additionally, the protective netting prevents the bag from tearing, even when sharp objects such as glass fragments are vacuumed up. Fine dust and lung-damaging particles cannot escape again.
Miele also offer a choice of three exhaust filters for their vacuums:
AirClean Filter - effective filtration for everyday needs.
Active AirClean Filter - reduces odors, good for pet owners.
HEPA AirClean Filter - filters even the finest dust and allergens – ideal for those with house dust allergies.
The current Miele range of vacuum cleaners consists of the following models in each category. There are different options to choose from within each model type allowing selection of additional features.
Miele Dynamic U1
Miele Classic C1 - light & functional
Miele Compact C2 - light & convenient
Miele Complete C3 - powerful & exceptional
Miele Triflex HX1
Miele Scout RX1
Dyson vacuum cleaners
Dyson aim to innovate with each new vacuum cleaner that they design. The Dyson brand grew rapidly due to the popularity of their root cyclone technology, which provided powerful suction without bags.
Their latest technology, Dyson Cinetic™ science, takes it to the next level - no filters. The Dyson Cinetic™ tips oscillate at up to 5,000 Hz, separating the microscopic dust and preventing it building up and blocking the airflow. There's no need for a pre-motor filter due to the efficiency of this dust separation technology. This translates to no loss of suction and no filters to replace or wash.
Dyson vacuums have other innovative features that you will find on specific models. All of their uprights and canisters feature their Dyson Ball™ technology for effortless maneuverability. Additionally, Dyson's "Animal" and "Allergy" models are specially designed for homes with pets and those with allergies.
The latest Dyson range of vacuum cleaners can be divided across the different categories as follows:
Dyson Cinetic Big Ball
Dyson Ball Compact
Dyson Small Ball
Miele vs Dyson - Uprights Compared
> Uprights - Miele Dynamic U1 Cat & Dog versus Dyson Cinetic Big Ball Animal Plus Allergy
For this Miele vs Dyson comparison we've used the latest upright vacuum cleaners from both brands. Both vacuum cleaners are suitable for pet owners because they can remove fur and pet hair easily as well as providing effective filtration of pet dander. They both retail for a similar price, although there are often some good discounts available on the Dyson, making it cheaper.
The vacuum cleaner is made using the latest technology from Dyson. With it, the cleaner is filterless and dust does not clog the air flows. The cleaner is suitable for cleaning pet hair as well as deep cleaning of carpets. It is suitable if you have hard floors, carpets and pets with long hair.
The Animal plus Allergy model comes with a multitude of hose attachments so you always have the best cleaning tool for the job at hand. The tools you will find in the box include:
Carbon fiber soft dusting brush
Reach under tool
Whole Machine HEPA Filtration.
Bagless, filterless and an airtight sealed system.
Dyson Ball technology for easy maneuvering.
Designed specifically for homes with pets.
A switch for brush to turn it on or off.
Auto wind cord.
13.4 inches wide cleaning head.
Cleans larger areas fast due to the wide cleaning head.
Dyson Cinetic technology means no filters to clean and no loss of suction, ever. Based on independent testing and user reviews this technology really works and the vacuum does indeed never lose suction. You will save money on running costs as there are no bags or filters to replace compared to a Miele.
The vacuum cleaner is attached with different tools that make it versatile at cleaning. You can use it to clean pet’s hair, crevices, upholstery and even areas that are difficult to reach.
The whole machine HEPA filtration ensures that only clean air is expelled. The vacuum is designed to remove not only dust, but also mold and mildew spores as well as allergens. It is recommended for asthma & allergy sufferers and is also certified asthma & allergy friendly.
May be heavy for some people. Although the weight is slightly lighter than the Miele Dynamic U1.
May not get far under the furniture due to the big ball and its wide cleaning head.
The bin capacity is 0.57 gallons, which is much smaller than the Miele U1's 1.35 gallon bag.
Although it is similar in price to the Miele U1, it is an expensive vacuum cleaner.
Fairly loud operation and much louder compared to the Miele Dynamic U1.
This video from Dyson provides an overview of the science behind the Dyson Cinetic Technology and how it is the only vacuum technology that has no loss of suction.
The Miele U1 Cat and Dog is Miele's top of the range upright vacuum cleaner designed specifically for pet owners. The multi-stage filtration ensures that 99.9% of fine dust is filtered and only clean air expelled. Additionally, the Active AirClean Filter has active charcoal layers to neutralize and absorb unwanted pet odors.
One feature on the Miele U1 that is not found on Dyson uprights is an LED headlight that brightly illuminates the area being cleaned. The following on-board tools are also included for use with the telescopic wand and hose:
Natural Fiber Dusting Brush
STB 101 Handheld Turbobrush
AirClean Sealed System.
Swivel neck technology.
Rotary dial speed control.
Hand held turbo brush.
Automatic height adjustment.
Active AirClean Filter.
The cleaning performance is the most impressive feature of the Miele Dynamic U1. The vacuum is highly rated for pet hair removal.
Built with durable materials like high density plastic and metal. German engineered to last 20 years.
Glides along floors - even though it is fairly heavy in weight, due to the swivel neck it is very easy to maneuver. Due to the automatic adjusting floor height sensor it is also easy to move from different heights of carpet, rugs, tile, and hardwood.
Incredibly quiet for such a powerful vacuum and much quieter than the Dyson Cinetic Big Ball Animal. The Miele sound level is around 80dB, which compares to 90dB for the Dyson.
Extra long cord means less time spent switching between power outlets. The overall cleaning radius is slightly more than the Dyson but the difference is minor. Both vacuums have a very long operating range.
The large capacity bag of the Miele U1 means that you will be able to vacuum longer between emptying in comparison to the Dyson Cinetic with its smaller bin.
The Miele Dynamic U1 is fairly heavy. It is slightly heavier than the Dyson. Although this doesn't affect its function, it is a consideration particularly if you need to lift it up and down stairs.
Cost of ongoing replacement of dust bags and filters. Although with the large HyClean dustbag you can vacuum a long time without having to replace the bag.
Expensive - although with the the combination of excellent performance, quality engineering and durability, the Miele Dynamic U1 offers value for money.
The video below provides a detailed look at the Miele Dynamic U1 Upright Vacuum in action. It shows off all of the features of the vacuum and is worthy of a watch if you are considering this model.
For this Miele vs Dyson contest we've taken the latest Dyson Canister featuring the Cinetic Science Technology and compared it to a Miele canister of a similar price. As we stated earlier, there is a large range of Miele canisters available. The model we've chosen here is their top line Miele Complete C3 model, however it is in the mid-price range of Miele canisters.
We've featured the Dyson Cinetic Big Ball Animal Canister in our Home Vacuum Zone reviews several times. The vacuum is highly rated for its strong suction power, ability to remove pet hair, excellent filtration and maneuverability.
Dyson Cinetic Science Technology - no loss of suction, ever.
No bags or filters to replace
Whole machine HEPA filtration
Ball technology - provides stability and a low centre of gravity for easy mobility and accurate steering when pulling it along.
Designed for homes with pets - the turbine tool is tangle free due to its counter-rotating heads.
Hygienic and quick to empty - just push the button to release the dirt.
Certified asthma & allergy friendly™ by Allergy Standards Limited.
Tangle-Free Turbine Tool
Carbon Fiber Turbinehead
Incredible lossless suction - this is the number one comment from the majority of users;
The telescoping tube extends effortlessly with a push of a button to about 4 feet long, which is longer than most other vacuums.
Very quiet, some users say this is so quiet they had to check it was working properly!
No bags to change or filters to clean - no ongoing costs unlike the Miele.
Great mobility due to the big ball design, moves easily across carpet & hard floors;
The carpet and floor brush combination tool is powered by vacuum power not an electrical brush making the wand and brush extremely lightweight.
No adjustment is necessary for floor or carpet height, it does it automatically
There is no storage for tools on the body of the cleaner. The wand caddy carries only two small accessories. There is no storage place to put the small furniture power head. This differs from the Miele Complete C3 which has storage for all its tools on board.
There is no height adjustment or being able to turn off the beater bar for differing pile carpets - except by using the controls to lessen the suction and slowing down the beater bar.
Many users have complained that the dust bin has to be emptied too often. The dust bin size is similar to other Dyson’s, however it is much smaller than the Miele's 1.2 gallon dust bag.
Miele has introduced the Limited Edition canister vacuum to their premium line C3 series for a short time only at a much lower price than the other canisters in the C3 range. We have included it in this Miele vs Dyson canister comparison as it is a similar price to the Dyson. It therefore offers fantastic value as the Miele Complete C3 vacuums are the most powerful and exceptional canisters in Miele's range. The C3 Limited Edition includes the Turbo brush and Combination brush, which are recommended for hard floors and area rugs.
6 suction settings with +/- footswitch pedals - select from 300-1200 watts.
Standard ergonomic handle
1200 watt, low-noise, high output Miele-made Vortex Motor System™
Lightweight skeleton construction
AirClean Sealed System™ Design retains 99.9% of particles inside the vacuum
AirClean filter captures 99.97% of all particles greater than 0.3 micron
Large capacity, AirClean filter bag w/ spring-loaded, self-sealing collar - type G/N, 4.76 qt.
AllTeQ Combination floor brush (SBD285-3) perfect for carpets and smooth surfaces
Turbo Comfort turbobrush (STB205-3) with air-driven brush roller - recommended for use on low-pile or cut-pile carpet and rugs
AirClean sealed filtration system keeps air fresh.
Powerful performance Vortex Motor with low-noise operation.
Turbo brush loosens dirt and hair from carpets.
3D bumper to protect against scruffs and scratches.
All of the attachments can be stowed away on board the canister.
Unmatched quality and reliability.
No exposure to allergens when emptying the collected dust and dirt.
HEPA filter is optional and does not come standard. You can buy this separately if you require.
The Miele Complete C3 is slightly heavier than the Dyson Canister but the difference is minor. The C3 is Miele's heaviest canister and it may feel slightly heavy for some users lifting it up and down stairs. If you prefer Miele vs Dyson canisters but are concerned about the weight check out our Miele Canister Reviews for other lighter options.
No filter change indicator
Ongoing cost of replacement bags and filters compared to the Dyson.
Here is a quick demonstration of the vacuum in action:
Miele's complete c3 CALIMA CANISTER
is available at a discount price on Amazon for a limited time:
The main differences between these two cordless sticks are that the Dyson V11 weighs slightly less than the Miele Triflex HX1, but its battery cannot be replaced and the Miele's can. Both of these cleaners provide excellent suction and cleaning performance. The entry level Miele model is also significantly cheaper than the Dyson but it does not come with HEPA filtration as standard.
The Dyson V11 Torque Drive is the latest installment in the Dyson Cordless stick range. All cordless vacuums are limited by their battery life and the Dyson V11 performs better than most in this regard. You get a number of attachments with this model, including the Torque drive head, mini-motorized tool, crevice tool, stubborn dirt brush, soft dusting brush and combination tool.
V11 Cordless Features
Up to 60 minutes of continuous suction. Trigger releases instantly. Battery power is only used for cleaning.
The Torque-drive cleaner head drives bristles deeper into the carpet to remove even more dirt.
Wall Mount for easy storage;
LED Screen display
Intelligently optimizes suction and run time across all floor types.
Top performing lightweight cordless cleaner
Converts to a handheld vacuum
Large dust bin (bigger than the Miele)
Entry level model only comes with one floor tool.
More expensive than the Miele.
There is no way of swapping out the battery with a spare so when your time is up you must wait to recharge before using again. The new Dyson V15 solves this!
Here is a demonstration of the Dyson V11 in action:
The Miele Triflex HX1 is Miele's first entry into cordless vacuuming. They have produced a strong competitor to challenge the Dyson V11 with this high performing model. In our recent review of the Miele Triflex HX1 there were some features that stood out as advantages versus the Dyson V11.
First of all the vacuum can be configured in 3 different ways to suit your cleaning plans. This compares to the 2 options you get with the Dyson V11 - either handheld or stick. The 3 modes that you get with the Miele Triflex HX1 are:
Reach Mode: Dustbin at the end of the stick and near the handle.
Comfort Mode: Dustbin right above the floorhead.
Compact Mode: Only dustbin with handle and smallmouth extension(without floorhead).
In addition, the vacuum's battery is replaceable, whilst the battery on the Dyson V11 is unfortunately not. The suction power of the Miele Triflex HX1 is also comparable to the Dyson V11 thanks to the Vortex technology combined with its powerful electrobrush.
Miele's Vortex technology delivers extreme suction power that is as strong as Miele's corded vacuums;
Extra wide powerful electrobrush - automatically adapts to different floor types;
Up to 60 minutes of runtime from a single battery charge
3 different cordless modes for flexible cleaning
LEDs on the edge of the cleaner head - make it easy to see dirt as you clean
3-level slide control for suction modes according to your needs
Wall mount included for easy storage
Can transform into several configurations for ultimate flexibility.
Lightweight and powerful suction.
Cheaper than the Dyson V11 Cordless.
Optional additional battery can be purchased (extra battery comes with the Miele Triflex HX1 Pro Model as standard)
Very quiet - only 70db when used on the most powerful setting on hard floors. The Miele Triflex HX1 Pro will be challenging for the quietest vacuum cleaner that we have reviewed to date!
The Miele Triflex is slightly heavier than the Dyson V11 at 8.8 lbs.
Filtration on the entry level Miele Triflex HX1 is not HEPA, although the filters provide a good standard of filtration (captures and filters 99.98% of all microscopic particles and allergens). The Lifetime Hygiene filter is a maintenance free filter, giving you piece of mind for the lifetime of your product. You can also optionally upgrade to a HEPA filter for even greater particle filtration, or this comes as standard with the "Cat & Dog" and "Pro" models.
No LCD screen like on the Dyson V11. So you need to glance down to check the power setting and there’s no way of gauging how much runtime is left in the battery either.
On the heavy side at 8.8lbs for a lightweight stick type but this is still a light & powerful vacuum cleaner.
Here is a closer look of the key exterior features of the Miele Triflex HX1:
Whether to choose a Miele or Dyson vacuum cleaner is a decision that should be based on your needs. This article has provided a detailed comparison of Miele and Dyson uprights, canisters and cordless stick models. Whilst the technology of these vacuums is quite different, the result is the same: exceptional performance and only clean expelled air.
Our preference leans towards Miele due to their vacuums being German engineered to last 20 years. We also think that bagged vacuums are better suited to allergy sufferers as they can be emptied without exposure to allergens. They also require less frequent emptying than the Dyson due to their extra large dust bags, which allow for quick and easy disposal. However you may prefer the convenience and lossless suction of the bagless and filterless technology offered by Dyson!
We hope that you've enjoyed this article and it has made the decision between Miele or Dyson easier for you! If you have any specific questions or feedback on this article we'd love to hear from you.
Last update on 2021-09-17 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
Robert is a vacuum cleaner fanatic and expert. He grew up repairing and selling vacuum cleaners in his Dad's home appliance sales and repair shop in the North of England, UK. When he's not reviewing vacuum cleaners for this site he likes to spend time with his partner and young daughter and he also works in construction as a Project Manager as his day job!
Home Vacuum Zone is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com